I made this Reindeer Eggnog recipe as a sponsored post for the Socialstars #donthesitaste campaign. Opinions are my own.
Although most of my parties don’t involve children anymore, holiday get-togethers are an exception. I have lots of little nieces and nephews, so I like to make sure I have a few things just for them.
One of our favorites is this Reindeer Eggnog. It’s a homemade version of the classic holiday drink, but it can be made two ways – Vixen-style (spiked for adults only) and Rudolph-style (non-alcoholic) for anyone.
I’ve never been one to “drink” my calories. I prefer to “crunch” them, so using Sweet ‘n Low in place of sugar to cut calories is where it’s at. Plus, it’s diabetic friendly, so I know all my guests and their children will be able to enjoy my holiday sips.
There aren’t a whole lot of ingredients in Reindeer Eggnog, so it’s fairly easy to make.
I cook eggs, spices and half and half over the stove until it reaches a safe temperature, and then I add some milk and Sweet ‘N Low sweetener before chilling it completely in the fridge.
If you want to serve the Reindeer Eggnog Vixen-style, it tastes incredible with fireball whiskey or spiced rum. I can’t decide which one I like best.
When it comes to the little ones, serve it Rudolph-style, and they’ll get a huge kick out of it!
Stick a maraschino cherry “Rudolph nose” on the edge of the glass and pop two cinnamon stick antlers inside the glass. Kids will love it!
Reindeer Eggnog - 2 Ways!
Ingredients
- 5 eggs
- 3 cups half and half
- ½ tsp pumpkin pie spice
- ¼ tsp nutmeg
- 1 ½ tsp vanilla
- 1 cup whole milk
- 14 packets Sweet 'N Low
- Optional: Fireball Whiskey or Spiced Rum for spiking :
Instructions
- Combine eggs, half and half, pumpkin pie spice and nutmeg in blender. Blend well.
- Pour into saucepan. Heat over low heat, stirring frequently, until mixture reaches 160 degrees. (About 15 minutes) Remove from heat.
- Whisk in vanilla and milk. Add Sweet 'N Low sweetener to taste.
- Chill completely in fridge.
- If spiking for adults, add whiskey or rum before serving.
Celeste says
This sounds delicious! And I love the little reindeer antlers and nose added to it! It is definitely the cherry on top! 😉
Pamela-FromMyFrontPorchToYours says
Sounds yummy!
Kelsie says
I’ve never thought of using pumpkin pie spice in egg nog! Brilliant!
Tonya C says
This Eggnog looks really fun to make and drink, I love this time of year when all the spirit goes into everything we buy, make, and eat!
Kristin says
Ive never had eggnog but these sound amazing. Thank you for sharing.
Amanda McMahon says
I’ve never had reindeer eggnog but have some regular stuff in the fridge… now to get the southern comfort or not…
Katarina says
I love how you take your photos! And I’ve been looking for a recipe like this, so thanks!
Mariana says
Love this! Eggnog is already good on its own, but adding the Rudolph garnish just makes it so much more festive!
LauraFunk says
Well I am totally naive. I did not think that egg nog actually was made with eggs. I thought it was just a fun name. Cool recipe
Margarita Ibbott (@DownshiftingPRO) says
Liz, you make some awesome cocktails. I love the visual of the reindeer one. Too cute. I pinned it to my pinterest board.
Ashley - Embracing Homemaking says
Ooh, I do love eggnog. It’s the perfect treat this time of year!
Amanda || Growing Up Madison says
OK so since I’m tired of boring eggnog because of the kids, I will have to try that spiked one. Sounds yummy!
Rebecca Swenor says
I love the reindeer eggnog idea. The eggnog is something my family loves during the holiday season and I have never made it homemade before. This is indeed a recipe I will be trying. Thanks for sharing the recipe.
Yona Williams says
I prefer ‘spiked’ eggnog for the holidays, and my Dad makes a mean concoction that will have you falling out of the chair. I am curious how eggnog tastes made with Sweet n Low.
Toni | BoulderLocavore says
LIZ! This is darling. I’ll taken mine Vixen-Style thank you but love he Rudolph version too. Really so creative.
Shannon Gurnee says
I agree with you Toni! This is such a cute idea! I love how creative and festive it is! So cute!
Kristen from The Road to Domestication says
I’ll admit, I’m not a fan of eggnog, but this looks really awesome! Maybe the twist will change my mind 🙂
Shannon Gurnee says
That is such a cute idea for the holidays! I love egg nog and this looks delicious!
April Mims says
Yum! This looks perfect for holiday celebrations, for adults and kids. I’ll have to try it this year.
JanetGoingCrazy says
This is the cutest drink ever! I love eggnog, but I’ve never had a recipe for it.
Chubskulit Rose says
My daughter was telling me a story about her classmates tradition with eggnog. I am glad you shared this, I might try to make some.
Terri Beavers says
Can you believe I’ve never tried eggnog before? I think it’s because of the eggs that I can’t make myself drink it. It looks good though.
Tami says
I love, love, love egg nog! I will be trying this recipe out (minus the alcohol). I’d love to be able to make it when my daughter drinks the last of it.
Jasmine Watts says
Wow, such a delicious treat to enjoy.. I will try this recipe in my kitchen too!!
Lisa says
What a fun twist on Egg-Nog. Perfect for our Christmas Eve party too!
Donna says
Confession: I’ve never tried eggnog before! I don’t like milk (unless it’s chocolate or in coffee) so rarely drink anything that has it in it, but that sounds amazing! I think the pumpkin spice would do it for me. And they looks so pretty, too!
Toughcookiemommy says
Egg nog is such a delicious treat to enjoy during the holidays. I love serving it this way for Christmas.
CourtneyLynne says
Omg this sounds so tasty!!! I just love fireball so I need to try this asap!
Shell says
I’m not a huge eggnog fan. But maybe I need to try it with fireball!
Chanelle says
I am not much of an eggnog drinker, but my dad lives for it this time of year. I need to share these with him. Thanks for sharing.
ashleigh says
I’m not much of an eggnog fan. But these look really cute, I would totally try the vixen one.
Toughcookiemommy says
I love egg nog. I have to agree with you, though, the vixen one is my favorite one too.
Dawn Nieves says
The spike one sounds yummy!!! I can’t get enough of the Rudolph version for the kids. It’s so cute!
Heather D. (@GirlGoneMom) says
I’ll take the spiked one please. I love the reindeer!
Jacqui Odell says
That sounds yummy! I need to try this sometime.
Cindy (Prime Beauty) says
Less calories? Yes please! I actually think I would like the non-spiked better!
Delaine says
I love eggnog, plus this looks delicious and tasty
lisa says
I love egg nog this time of year. This is a great way to spice up ordinary egg nog!
Melissa says
My husband and daughter both love Egg Nog. I would love to let them try this version with less sugar, it sounds great!
rika says
This is a cute recipe! I love egg nog, I prefer non alcoholic and low in sugar recipe! So this is a perfect recipe for me
Christie says
How adorable with the cherry nose on the glass! I’ve never tried making eggnog at home, great idea!
Mama to 5 BLessings says
That is such a great idea! Make it virgin, my kids would love this!
Dogvills says
I love egg nog! I can’t wait to try the alcohol free recipe.
Brenda Brown says
I am going to have to try this recipe for my family.
angela@spinachtiger says
I’ll take the one with the rum, and I like not using sugar. I’m like you. I eat my calories.
ricci says
Both of these Reindeer Eggnog recipes sound delish!! I need a new eggnog recipe and just may have to try one of these!
Claudette says
I am not a big lover of eggnog but the way you decorate the glass is really cute!
Keikilani says
Your recipe sounds really yummy. Love that you have two ways to enjoy!
Eileen says
My family loves eggnog! This is a delicious recipe! I love your names too – Vixen for adults! Fabulous! Thank you for sharing! My family will love this recipe and especially using sweet n low!
Amber Louchart (Metro Detroit Mommy) says
This looks so delish. Fantastic job on your images. I haven’t tried eggnog in years, I will save this recipe to try later.
Stephanie of The TipToe Fairy says
Can you believe I’ve never tried eggnog? I am love these reindeer versions. Too cute!
Ellen ThatChicMom says
Great recipe! My husband loves eggnog but I have never made it, I think he needs a Christmas surprise.
Alicia says
This looks pretty good. I’ve never had eggnog, so I may give this one a try. Great idea for Christmas coming up.
Tracey says
What a fun recipe. I love that there’s less sugar than typical holiday drinks and I will take mine spiked please!
Rosey says
Turning the cup into a reindeer was a really cute idea. I think this sounds great either version.
Nikki @ Tikkido says
I’ve never thought of using fireball whisky to spike eggnog, but that sounds pretty fabulous! My parents always used brandy, and that just covered up the delicious eggnog flavor, so I never went for it.
OurFamilyWorld says
Both recipes sound great. I can’t wait to try them both.
victoria says
Such a fun idea and it looks really good. I will bookmark this
Maureen@ADebtFreeStressFreeLife says
Both of these eggnogs sound really delicious. For me I would probably do without the Sweet and Low and use something more natural but if you’re watching your calories or are diabetic the sweet and low is a great option.
OurFamilyWorld says
Aw, that is too cute! The girls will love this.
Onica {Mommy Factor} says
What a great Idea indeed. Its really looks cute and yummy. My kids will surely love this for sure.
Cat Davis says
You know what, I’ve never actually had any idea what the heck eggnog is!?! I’ve always avoided it because I thought it was some strange raw egg drink lol But that actually sounds good, kinda like a thin custard.
Nikki says
I’m sure my kids would love this reindeer eggnog. It looks yummy and tasty.
Tonya C says
This sounds and looks really good , might make it on christmas.
Maurene says
This can be a great snack for the children. The reindeer idea looks fun and cute.
Mardene Carr says
Egg Nog….that famous drink…great spin
Maurene says
These are truly perfect for the children. The reindeer look seems to be so cute to be eaten.
tiaras and tantrums says
I have never tried to make homemade egg nog – I imagine it tastes much better than store purchased? My entire family loves a boozy egg nog -(adults – not kiddos) ☺
Amanda says
My kids were just asking for eggnog today!
Kristi says
Yum… I love eggnog. I have to admit I have never had it “spiked”, but just might have to try it now that you gave a good recipe for it.
Michelle says
okay the reindeer eggnog is just too cute with the cherry for the nose
Vera Sweeney says
I love a good eggnog!! This sounds delicious, plus I love you can make them for kids with out the rum in it.
Crystal says
So fun, right? My kiddos are crazy festive. I want to embrace it and make their holidays full of fun surprises!
Miles L. says
This recipe is awesome. I’ll save this one. I am thinking to try this during my vacation.
Kelly Hutchinson says
I never thought about making egg nog at home. I love spiked egg nog. I usual use Captain Morgan.
Amber NElson says
Now that looks like eggnog even I would like!
Brandy M. says
My clan all loves Egg Nog and this is such a festive way to serve it for the holidays. I like that you cut out some of the calories by using Sweet N Low because Egg Nog can be very high in calories.
valmg @ From Val's Kitchen says
What a totally cute idea! I’ve never tried making my own egg nog, your recipe makes it sound simple enough.
Athena says
Oh my gosh my kids would absolutely love this. They are huge eggnog fans and this would be so much better!
Theresa says
My husband was just asking me why I didn’t make homemade egg nog. Well, now I don’t have an excuse. These look scrumptious!
Lauren @ Mom Home Guide says
This looks so good! Love the way you styled it, too!
Lisa Joy Thompson says
This is such a fun idea! I’m now imagining all kind of Rudolph drinks for my kiddos!
Rachel Mouton says
This is adorable! My kids would love it 🙂
Elizabeth O. says
How can you not love this drink! Thanks for sharing! I can’t believe I never thought about doing this myself. So easy to do!
Heather says
Looks like a fun drink! I didn’t know about fireball whiskey though. Might have to find of that!
Chastity says
I have never had eggnog! Yours looks amazing – will have to make some for our Christmas party.
Jeanine says
This is awesome. I love the cherry on the glass like that. That’s brilliant! I would for sure go for the rudolph style!
Cristine says
Heard there was an egg nog shortage this year. I hope that I can find some so that I can creat these recipes
Sicorra@NotNowMomsBusy says
I know the egg nog you buy in stores is filled with carbs and calories, but I have never tried to make my own. Thanks for sharing your delicious recipe 🙂
Shauna says
Now these look amazing. I love that you made a non-alcoholic. This would be fun for Christmas day (And maybe the alcoholic one for Christmas Eve) Thanks for sharing
Scarlet says
This is so cute. I love the way you styled the eggnog into a cute reindeer. Eggnog is a big holiday favorite at my house.
Seattle Travel Blogger says
Nice recipe presentation here…will have to give this a go.
Thanks for the holiday treat!
gingermommyrants says
Spiked Eggnog is so delicious to sip on in front of a cozy fire. I will have to try this recipe. It looks delicious.
Tammi Roy says
I love eggnog . This is a delicious and easy recipe to make. I will have to give it a try for the holidays.
Ann Bacciaglia says
This is a great drink recipe. I will have to try the spiked version when i have company this weekend.
Angela says
I have never seen egg nog served like this before. That reindeer is so stinkin’ cute! I’ll be doing this at my holiday party this year!
Patrice M Foster says
Eggnog looks tempting but I don’t like the aftertaste from artificial sweetners. Your recipe is simple to try and make this holiday thanks for sharing.
Stacie says
I would love to make my own eggnog. They look so delicious and cute with the Rudolph nose.
CAROL CASSARA says
I can not use artificial sweeteners, but I adore eggnog no matter how it’s made. This looks good!
andi says
you could also use stevia to sweeten the recipe up – it’s SO good! 🙂
Crystal says
So cute! I don’t think my kids have ever had eggnog before, so it’ll be an extra special treat. Plus the cherry nose!
Meagan says
eggnog is one of my husband’s favorite drinks! I bet he would love this! Plus, the presentation is gorgeous!
Jennifer Sikora says
I have never been a big fan of egg nog. I just cannot get past the taste. However, if it was spiked, I might like it better!
tara pittman says
My husband loves eggnog and the store brand is expensive. I need to make this.
Meagan says
I know, right? What a great alternative to store bough egg nog. I bet it tastes better too!
Michelle T says
That looks really good. Wish my husband liked eggnog then I would try this out.
Jennifer H says
You’re so creative Liz! Love the cute red nose. 😉 And great recipes ideas!
Lady Lilith says
Such a cute cup. I love how festive it looks. Great idea.
Shaylee says
This looks so yummy, especially the Vixen style! haha I never really think to make fancy drinks around Christmas time but maybe I should start!
Ana De- Jesus says
I will have Rudolph thanks mine is on the house 🙂 great recipes and I like that you accommodated to all preferences.
Heather lawrence says
We are HUGE eggnog fans here…add a little spiced rum and you know it’s going to be a great night!
Never tried making my own before but the recipe looks super easy.
Jeanette says
My hubby is BIG fan of eggnog and I never knew how to make it. I will have to try this recipe!
Jennifer says
That eggnog looks great! I think the “nose” is a nice touch. I’ll have to make this for my next holiday get together.
Travel Blogger says
These are so cute! I love a good holiday drink.
Mama to 5 BLessings says
How adorable is that! What a great recipe to make for gatherings this time of the year!
Kait says
Mmmmm! This looks delicious!
aimee fauci says
I have never made my own eggnog. I bet it tastes a million times better. Looks too cute.
Pam says
I love eggnog but I haven’t made my own in a while. I need to do this, I love the cute reindeer garnishes.
Chrystal | Nevermore Lane says
I am like you, I prefer to chew my calories, not drink them. I really have to watch my sugars/carbs now so this egg nog recipe is perfect for me.
Stacie @ Divine Lifestyle says
I love this so much. The little antlers make it for me. <3
deanna says
We are having an ugly sweater party this weekend, I will have to try this.
Sylvia Jules Kal says
What???
Now I have heard it all…an ugly sweater party lol.
Liz I am not one for eggnog but the Vixen one is pulling me…lol Maybe because if that shot of whiskey or Rum 🙂
Susan Mary Malone says
This looks wonderful! I love homemade eggnog and will try this recipe this weekend!
Emerald says
I’ll take some of that! The best part of Christmas – other than family, of course – is eggnog. Yum!
Lauren @ Mom Home Guide says
Looks great! My kids love eggnog, so I will try your recipe! I love how cute the glass looks!
Jessica Harlow says
I’ve been looking for an alcoholic eggnog recipe and this is perfect! We’ll be trying this over the holidays!
Jaime says
The drink sounds fabulous (especially the Vixen version, which I can’t have for a few more months.) They’re also adorable! I’m having a small party this Sunday. I may have to try this for my group!
MJ L. commenting for Mommyhastowork says
Yum that sounds so good! Perfect for a holiday party, adults can enjoy and the kids can have a kid friendly version of the drink.
Rebecca Bryant says
How delicious. I like your sweet-n-low version. I am all about trying to save a few calories but not give up taste.
Ciao Florentina says
This is so cute ! You got me craving egg nog in the middle of the night ! Such a fun idea !
Marielle Altenor says
Would you believe that I have never tried eggnog before? This recipe sounds yummy!
Raijean says
Now that looks so good and for half the calories, I’m sold!
Jennifer says
too too cute. I love that it’s “vixen-style”! that’s hilarious. I totally pinned that one. I’ve actually never made my own eggnog at home because all the recipes I’ve seen have raw egg in them – NO THANK YOU! Thank goodness you cook the egg in your recipe!
Saidah Washington says
This is so yum Liz!! I made eggnog for the first time this week. Can’t believe it’s so simple
Heather Johnson says
This holiday-themed egg nog is too cute! I am so pinning this to my Christmas board!
Robin (Masshole Mommy) says
I love that you can make this spiked or virgin for the kids. I am going to go with the Vixen, though 😉
Jennifer says
that’s the best but especially the cute cherry Rudolph nose for the “kid” version!
Autumn @ Mamachallenge says
That is so cute! I think my kids would really like to help make these.
Robin (Masshole Mommy) says
My kids always love helping me make stuff. too! Good idea to have them help with this 🙂