Muffin Bottom Pudding Pie…
If you’re a Gilmore Girls fan, and I most definitely am, you’ll remember when Sookie talked about making a pudding pie with muffin bottoms.
Well, since the show is back on Netflix now (woohoo!) with the four-part Gilmore Girls: A Year in the Life, it seems the perfect time to make one, don’t you think?
This recipe came from the must-have Eat Like a Gilmore – the unofficial cookbook for fans of Gilmore Girls. I don’t normally buy cookbooks surrounding fictional characters, but this is Gilmore Girls.
Had to have.
You can’t help but fall in love with the quirky characters and their unique traditions: Friday night dinners, late-night chit chats, coffee at Luke’s, Sookie’s kitchen mishaps. Having the chance to join them for any or all of these things makes me happy!
So does this Sookie-inspired pudding pie.
It’s so messy, but oh, so good.
So queue up the Gilmore Girls reboot or heck, pick a great movie, and have a bite!
{Eat Like a Gilmore Kristi Carlson Unofficial Cook book}{Eat Like a Gilmore}
Jell-O Instant French Vanilla Pudding & Pie Filling (3.4 oz Box)Pyrex Glass Bakeware Pie Plate 913.5 oz. Box Keebler Graham Cracker CrumbsTalking as Fast as I Can: From Gilmore Girls to Gilmore Girls (and Everything in Between)
Gilmore Girls Muffin Bottom Pudding Pie
Gilmore Girls Muffin Bottom Pudding Pie
Ingredients
Crust
- 1/2 cup butter melted
- 2 cups graham cracker crumbs
- 1/4 cup sugar
Filling
- 1 5.1oz box vanilla instant pudding mix
- 3 cups cold milk
- 16 oz tub Cool Whip
- 6 large muffin bottoms
Instructions
Make crust:
- In a medium bowl, mix melted butter with crushed graham crackers and sugar. When mixture looks like wet sand, press it into the bottom and sides of a standard 8-inch pie pan.
Make filling:
- In a medium bowl, fold pudding into whipped topping until fully blended.
Assemble pie
- With a sharp knife, slice muffin bottoms in half horizontally, so you have two circles from each muffin bottom. Place six slices on graham cracker crust to create a muffin bottom layer. Using half of the whipped topping pudding mix, layer over the muffin bottom layer, filling in the spaces between muffin pieces. Place remaining six slices of muffin bottoms on top of that, and finally add remaining whipped topping/pudding mix to cover muffin pieces.
Amy Orvin says
That pie looks amazing! I used to watch Gilmore Girls all the time. It’s the first time I laid eyes on Jared Padalecki. Yummm!!
Hesper Fry says
Wow! This recipe looks so good. I would love to try it.
Barbara Montag says
This has to be the most delicious looking pie I’ve ever seen!
Seyma Shabbir says
The pie looks amazing! Can you believe I never saw this show!
sahana says
Looks so amazing! Thank you for linking with us at #HomeMattersParty . We would love to have you again next week.
Cynthia R says
THis pie looks amazing. I missed out on the Gilmore girls when I was younger, need to watch it so I can watch the Netflix reboot.
Dana Rodriguez says
That looks delicious! I will be making this pie very soon!
Natalie says
I prefer pudding and chocolate over fruit pies. I will have to make this for my family sometime!
Lauren Jones says
Oh my goodness my mouth is watering!!! That sounds and looks so good!!!
Elena says
This looks so delicious and amazing. I would love to try it
Mami2jcn says
That dessert looks so decadent and delicious!
Cynthia C says
Looks great! I’d like to try it with home made pudding and real whipped cream. I think that would taste amazing.
Janet W. says
I’m a huge fan of any kind of pie. This looks absolutely delicious and easy to make. My family would enjoy it!
Karen Glatt says
Oh how wonderful this recipe is and I want to make the Gilmore Girls Muffin Bottom Pudding Pie! It looks easy to make and so delicious. Thanks for sharing a really good recipe.
Sarah Bailey says
This looks absolutely amazing! I am definitely going to be giving this a try soon.
Brianne says
This looks so yummy, I want to eat it now. And I just love that the Gilmore Girls are back!
Melisasource says
This looks delicious!!! I will have to whip this up for sure!
Christina Aliperti says
I remember that! I think this pie looks amazing and I have to try it. while watching Gilmore Girls of course.
Dawn McAlexander says
I guess you could count this as comfort food to watch the Gilmore Girls with. That makes sense, doesn’t it? I think that would be a great idea, personally.
kristin says
Oh my gosh this sounds so good!!! Perfect to go with the show!
Crystal says
Yes please! I loved the Gilmore Girls, and was so excited for this new installment. Definitely need to go back & rewatch with a whole lot of this pie.
Toni | Boulder Locavore says
Oh yes! This looks SO good! I can’t wait to try this at home while watching Gilmore Girls!
Ann Bacciaglia says
Muffin bottom pudding pie looks so delicious and easy to make. I will have to get the ingredients I need to make this for dessert this weekend.
Theresa says
I wish I had Sookie as my personal chef. I think this cookbook will have to suffice though. The pudding pie sounds amazing!
Kristi says
Oh that looks absolutely delicious! A fun time… sit and watch the show with a friend and eat that!
Christie says
Sounds like the perfect eats for watching Gilmore Girls! Muffin bottom, now I totally want to make this
Reesa Lewandowski says
I need a BIG slice of this!!!!! I need to watch this still!
Marcie W. says
I am so excited to be able to journey back to Stars Hollow. This treat looks like the perfect Gilmore Girls binge companion.
Pam says
My friend’s daughter is obsessed with Gilmore Girls. This pie would be right up her alley to binge watch the new series.
Cassie Tucker says
This is such a unique dessert idea! I’m totally making this for my mother-in-law this weekend because I think she will just devour it!
Colleen Lanin says
That pie looks so amazing! If this recipe is representative of the entire cookbook, I have to add it to my cookbook library.
Jen Rattie says
I must have this cookbook! I’m a huge Gilmore Girls fan, and I love to cook new recipes. This is so perfect for me.
Stacie @ Divine Lifestyle says
Yes! Get in my belly, you delicious dessert! Get right in there. I am making this come the weekend. And I am NOT sharing!